Sunday, August 16, 2009

Restoring Confidence to the Banking System

A few months ago, i wrote an article pleading with the then Governor of the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) to allay our fears about the state of our banks. Alas Professor Soludo did not do much to calm my nerves. Since my plea, a new Governor, Sanusi Lamido has taken over the leadership of the CBN from Soludo whose term expired in May.

On 14th August, less than 3 months after taking over, Sanusi Lamido acted decisively to deal with the uncertainty hanging over the banks by sacking the Managing Directors of Afribank, Finbank, Intercontinental, Oceanic and Union Bank. In his view these 5 banks pose a serious threat to the financial system and the management of the banks have acted in a manner detrimental to the interest of their depositors and creditors. The CBN was forced to act to save depositors and restore confidence to the banking system.

In my view, this is a welcome development. In a time of crisis, there is often a need to show leadership and act decisively. For almost a year, the 5 banks have been suffering from illiquidity, surviving on the Expanded Discount Window and interbank borrowings. As the Governor said, three of the banks were very important to the banking system and something needed to be done before they lead to a collapse of the financial system.

The Governor’s actions required courage. For there are vested interests that would have done everything possible to stop this decisive action. However, the actions of the CBN are in order and are in the interest of depositors and long suffering investors. Some of the actions of the banks were shocking. Take Intercontinental bank for example. The bank loaned out more than thirty four billion Naira to three companies they themselves called “fringe” players in the downstream sector of Oil and Gas. It is shocking that such huge sums will be loaned out to three companies that have no significant record of success to speak of. Where was the risk management?

Then there are the billions loaned out to speculators on the Nigerian Stock Exchange (NSE) in the form of margin loans. The value of the securities have since collapsed by more than 70% in some cases. In the process trillions of Naira vanished.

The management of these banks have shown themselves not capable of managing the growth experienced by the banks. Within three years the five banks have frittered away more than three hundred billion Naira in fresh capital. The CBN did the right thing by sacking the managers. Something needed to be done to save what is left of the banks.

Depositors should remain calm. The CBN has injected over 400 billion Naira to save these banks in an unprecedented move backing its words that no bank will be allowed to fail.

It is my hope that these actions by the CBN will restore confidence to the system, reduce the cost of funds and lead to recovery of the economy in general.

Monday, August 3, 2009

Redemption

We are in the summer and it is meant to be quite but the NSE has been simmering in the last couple of trading days. The NSE All share Index has gone up for 8 straight days and is on the brink of a possible gain on day 9.

In the last 18 months i have come to realise that a lot of things are very possible on the NSE. The expectation is that with the common year end, the last qtr will be tight. But then the CBN cut the Monetary Policy Rate. Oil price has stabilized above $55 for some time reducing the federal deficit. In the last 1 week the Naira has fallen in the official market to N150.25 to the $ further reducing the deficit. So despite the collapse of power and security concerns, the economy is looking like it may finally get some life. Furthermore world markets are looking up with the Dow crossing 9,000.

Looking at the NSE Index it has now gone up for 8 trading days. It faltered on 30th July but did not go down and then it went up on 3rd August when it looked like it might be on its way down. The last time this sort of resistance happened was between 16th April and 24th. It had earlier happened between 1st to 7th April. It was thus in April that the Index resisted a fall and then burst up in May. It then went on that remarkable run that saw it come within whiskers of the year opening value.

However, a not very common occurrence is that the value of transactions went up gradually for 6 trading days starting on 24th July and reaching a climax on 31st July. Value fell today. Is that the sign of a reversal? Or are we about to see another remarkable run? Possibly. Will i be happy if the Index continues to go up carrying us towards another remarkable gain? Yes off course! It will offer me another opportunity to quietly take some gains. I have already realigned my portfolio to my satisfaction but i have learnt it pays to graciously accept unreasonable gains.

For those considering buying into the market, i will say exercise due care and do not get caught out in what might be a suckers rally. Ensure you have tight stops for any speculative buy.

Perhaps this is the chance for some smart banks to quietly and slowly get rid of the toxic assets in their books and in the process get much needed liquidity boost and offer beleaguered shareholders some redemption.

Saturday, August 1, 2009

Beyond the Write Offs

It is no longer news that our banks will need to make provisions against losses from margin and downstream oil sector loans. ETI set the ball rolling by releasing a very disappointing full year result. This was followed by FBN writing off N26 billion to everyone’s surprise. However, not many were surprised when Oceanic bank set a record by writing off N42 billion in one swoop.

Since then Zenith, Oceanic and UBA have released their quarterly results and all 3 have written off billions. I expect all the other banks to follow suit with write offs in their quarterly announcements. I am glad the banks have decided to come clean after being helped along by the new CBN governor. As an insider the Governor was very aware of the extent of the problem at least in FBN.

While i welcome the write offs so that we can move forward, i believe the management of the banks need to show some accountability. It is not just enough to write off billions and pretend all is well. We as shareholders need to know what management has put in place to avoid a future recurrence of almost complete breakdown in risk management. We need to know whether the key parties in the debacle have been sanctioned appropriately. As a minimum no one should get a performance bonus after such disastrous results. For many years bank executives have been handsomely compensated on the back of good results. Now that the tide has changed we expect to see some restraint on executive compensation.

I therefore call on all shareholders to attend the Annual General Meeting and voice their concerns. We need to see some remorse from management for such wealth destruction. We also need to hear what they are doing to avoid recurrence. Hopefully the end of the era of praise singing at AGM’s is in sight.

Saturday, July 18, 2009

Round 2

Someone once said “the ability to anticipate the market instead of reacting to it is the most important attribute that separates the consummate investor from the rest of the investing crowd”. Can we anticipate the market? Perhaps. Attempting to predict the direction of the market is usually a fools errand, but there is no harm in trying.

There is no doubt we are in bear territory. The NSE All Share Index has lost 23.5% since it peaked for the year at 30,925 on 2nd June. On June 2nd , the market had by then been on a spectacular run and was up a stunning 56% since its low of 19,804 established on 26th March. It was an incredible reward for those who went in during the dismal first quarter. Therefore the current bear run is not shocking when considered alongside the remarkable gains.

So how can we recognise the signs of a recovery from the current bear run? Can we anticipate the next bull and jump in at close to the bottom? Back in late January when i decided to jump back in big time it was because i felt stocks were cheap using various valuation methods. Using Price to Earnings (PE), Price to Book and Dividend Yield, stocks were selling at 4 year lows. The average Yield at the end of January was 6% while the PE was 14.3. That compared favourably with the average of 16.3 and Yield of 4.75% on 30th December 2005. The market did not bottom out until March after a suckers rally in February. At the bottom of the market on 26th March 2009 the yield was 6% and PE 12.5%. However, all the stocks i bought in late January and early February did not breach their lows in the March sell off. What i did not anticipate then was that i will be rewarded so quickly.

I used mainly two criteria to decide what to buy: the dividend yield and the PE. I placed more emphasis on the dividend yield. Deciding that at worst i will get a dividend. Most of the banks stood out. I selected those i was familiar with and those that have taken the worst beating. A number of non bank stocks also stood out. I bought those with the largest yields and a reasonable dividend paying record. I avoided Insurance companies. Having just taken a course on Risk management, the faith of Insurance companies in the UK during the stock market collapse in the early 2000’s kept ringing in my ears. Despite their “attractive” valuations i stayed away.

Within two weeks of my entry the February suckers rally was in full swing. I sold a few to reduce my losses from the previous year but mercifully held on most until May/June. I guessed correctly that the stocks had more to run and that they were still fundamentally attractive. Anticipating a selloff in the 3rd quarter i decided to bank some of my gains, I took out all the cash i put in during the first quarter plus more in May and June. I rebalanced my portfolio keeping a few banks and buying more non banks that i hope will act as stabilizers. I kept a nice amount of cash to take advantage of any opportunities that might arise. So far so good.

July has so far been testing. The Index has gained only 3 times in 13 trading days shedding 11.9% in the process. The average PE as at July 17th was 13 and the Yield 5%. The PE is now more attractive than in January but the Yield has dropped probably reflecting some of the poor dividends announced by some Insurance companies. A few stocks are definitely becoming more attractive. My eyes are firmly on non banks stocks for now. The banks need to fall further to compensate for the more uncertainty hanging over them. Insurance stocks are still a no go.

Another positive development that might affect the faith of the market is the reduction in Monetary Policy Rate by the Central Bank. Lower interest rates are generally good for the economy and the market.

I still believe the last half of the year will be tough due to the common year end for banks and the painful write downs some banks need to make. However, if one has a thick skin and some cash to last a long bear run, it will also present an opportunity.

The strategy is to try hard not to exhaust cash before the bear is finally slaughtered. Buy in bits and avoid needless risk like buying IAA or Transcorp for instance. And above all be patient and prepared for a long, bumpy and exhausting ride.

Sunday, July 12, 2009

Ray of Hope

May provided further respite and ray of hope to beleaguered investors on NSE. The Index gained a stunning 38% , surely a record gain in any one month. It was a month in which investors who took the risk in the first quarter were rewarded beyond their imagination. Value of transaction at just over N56 billion was the highest for the year which is consistent with a rising market which generates more interest.

June on the other hand was a reality check. Value of transactions at over N94 billion was the highest in 9 months. The Index reached a year high on June 2nd at 30,925 and came within whiskers of the year opening. However, by the end of the month the Index had dropped to 26,862 a 9.6% decline from May closing. This was certainly not a surprise after the record setting gains in May.

As we enter the summer the dullest time of the year, it is likely that the index will drop further from its June closing before the summer is out. Already the first few days in July indicate a declining interest in the market. Value of transactions are declining daily albeit slowly. But the signs of a bear market are there: lower lows and lower highs combined with shrinking volume.

With the new Central Bank Governor talking tough and uncertainty still hanging over the faith of some banks this is the time for caution. A time to perhaps sit still. Except for some investors still holding on to dead wood. This might be another opportunity to exit with modest losses before another round of meltdown.

Thursday, April 30, 2009

April

April brought welcome relief after the destruction in March when the All Share Index lost 15.1% closing at 19.852. This was the first time it closed for the month below 20,000 since November 2003.

Mercifully April was much better, in fact better than February as the Index gained 8.7% closing at 21,491. The full year result for GTB contributed to the positive performance of the Index. The Index gained 8.3% in 7 days following the release of the result. Without the positive impact of GTB, the month would have closed almost flat.

The full year result of GTB restored some confidence to the beleaguered market. The level of disclosure was impressive and the performance above expectations in the light of the gloom. The result lifted some of the clouds hovering over the banks.

The value of transactions in April was also encouraging. Although just under N43 billion was exchanged a far cry from the N250 billion that was exchanged in April last year, it was the highest for the year. Indicating investors are becoming more interested in the market.

May will be pivotal. Will the gains made in April be reversed just as we saw in March? Or would the flurry of full year results (Oceanic, Ecobank, Dangote Sugar etc) and quarterly results (Zenith, UBA, Skye etc) lift the market?

That said, the feeling is that the worst is over. The Index might commence mild fluctuations till the last quarter of the year. In general the faith of the market, just like its capitalization rests on the performance of the banks. As the banks perform so will the Index. Let’s hope the result released by GTB is an indication of positive news to come.

Thursday, March 26, 2009

Capping of Interest Rates

The Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) issued a circular on 23rd March 2009 on bank interest rates. The CBN was concerned that interest rates have gone out of hand and something needs to be done. To address this, the Bankers Committee met on 21st March (a Saturday) to discuss. The circular was to communicate the decisions taken. The key ones were:

1) Henceforth, banks will not seek deposit at rates exceeding 15%
2) The lending rate of banks will not exceed 22% plus a maximum of 2% in fees
3) The CBN will lend to banks at a rate that is not higher than 5% above the Monetary Policy Rate (MPR).

The question is why are interest rates high in both the retail and interbank markets? Probably because there is a liquidity crisis and the banks don’t trust each other. Hence require higher rates to compensate them for the risk they are taking by lending to each other. The next question then is how will fixing rates solve the liquidity crisis?

In my view, fixing the rates will not solve the underlying crisis, which is lack of cash by banks. We have seen the effect of trying to force the market with the 1% downward rule of Nigeria Stock Exchange (NSE) and the recent closure of the Interbank Foreign Exchange market. Both measures ended up eroding confidence and had the reverse effect.

I would have thought the first thing CBN will do is to reduce the MPR. With the MPR at 9.75% the CBN is in an enviable position as it can cut rates. Some central banks have lost this option long ago. Why not drop the rate to say 7.75% and the maximum spread for lending to banks to be 3% above MPR? This should help reduce cost of funds as some banks will decide it makes financial sense to access the expanded discount window rather than access the interbank market.

Perhaps another thing that can be done is to inject more money into the economy. An idea is for the Federal Government, States and Local Governments share some more from the excess crude account. The money was saved for the rainy day. Now is the time to use it. The Federal Government can use its share to pay off the billions owed to contractors. They can also use the money for needed capital projects such as completing fast some of the Power Plants already in progress. With this more cash will flow into the banks and reduce the liquidity crisis.

The CBN has been very market oriented in the last few years. However, it has shown in the last 6 months that it is running out of ideas. Perhaps the CBN needs to work with the executive and legislature to find a way out the of the liquidity crisis that has been lingering on for over 9 months. The capping of rates can be interpreted as a cry for help. The Executive and Legislature should step up and offer help before it is too late.